Nucor (NUE) Deep Dive: Why We Own It

Watch: Why We Own Nucor (NUE)

A short video deep dive on this topic. Prefer to read? The full post is below.

Why We Own Nucor (NUE)

Nucor is a current holding. A few numbers explain the position, and each is read from our own data pull as of the close on July 31, 2026.

• Operating margin near 16%. Over the last twelve months Nucor turned about 16% of sales into operating profit. The median for other listed US steelmakers is roughly 8%.
• Net margin of 8%. That is more than double the roughly 3% earned by the steel-peer group.
• A +82% one-year return, more than double the +33% median of its steel peers.
• Record revenue, low price. Sales in the most recent quarter grew 23% from a year earlier to a record $10.4 billion, yet the shares trade near 14 times next year's expected earnings.

None of this is a personal opinion on steel. Nucor rose to the top of a systematic screen that weighs profitability, the quality and direction of earnings, and price strength. The Optimizer then selected it. Every name in the book must re-qualify against the same screen each month. Data-driven, not gut-driven.

At a Glance

The first table is Nucor's own snapshot. All figures are as of the close on July 31, 2026.

The second table compares Nucor against two peer groups on the metrics that matter most.

Two peer sets sit behind those columns, both computed by us from primary fundamentals data. The direct steel-peer set is the six US-listed producers closest to Nucor's business: Steel Dynamics (STLD), Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF), Commercial Metals (CMC), United States Steel (X), Worthington Steel (WS) and Reliance (RS). We left out foreign-listed producers such as ArcelorMittal, Ternium and Gerdau, whose results reflect different tax, subsidy and currency conditions. The broad set is the 100 largest US-listed companies in the Materials sector, which also includes chemicals, industrial gases and mining.

The chart below adds our own position to that snapshot. It shows Nucor's share price over the last three months, with our average entry price marked. A live position is past performance, not a forecast.

Best in Steel, Ordinary Against the Broad Sector

Steel is a thinner-margin business than the average materials company. The broad Materials median operating margin is near 23%, lifted by specialty chemicals and industrial-gas firms that sell higher-value products. Measured against that blended figure, Nucor's 16% looks ordinary, and we will not pretend otherwise.

The fair comparison is Nucor against other steelmakers. There it stands apart. Its operating margin is roughly double the steel-peer median, its net margin about two and a half times the group, and its one-year return more than double. The gap is structural, not luck. Nucor runs the lowest-cost mills, owns much of its own scrap and raw-material supply, and spreads production across sheet, plate, bar and finished steel products, so a soft patch in one market rarely sinks the whole company.

The Business: What Nucor Actually Makes

Nucor makes steel and steel products, and it is the largest steel producer in the United States. The company runs three parts. Steel Mills produce the raw sheet, plate, bar and structural steel that go into cars, buildings, bridges and appliances. Steel Products turn that steel into finished items such as joists, decking, rebar and fasteners. Raw Materials gathers and processes the scrap metal that feeds the mills, which means Nucor controls much of its own supply chain.

Nucor's mills are electric-arc furnaces, the approach known as the mini-mill model. This is the heart of the cost advantage. A blast-furnace mill runs hot around the clock and loses money when it idles. A mini-mill can throttle output with demand. That flexibility is why Nucor stays profitable in downturns that push higher-fixed-cost rivals into losses.

“The question is never whether steel is a good business. It is whether you own the lowest-cost, most flexible producer in it. That is Nucor.”

A Balance Sheet Built for the Cycle

Quality shows up on the balance sheet as much as on the income statement. Against $5.7 billion of EBITDA in the last twelve months, Nucor carries only about $4.4 billion of net debt. It has raised its dividend every year for more than five decades, a record that puts it among the small group of dividend aristocrats, while paying out less than a fifth of its earnings. Low debt and a low payout leave room to keep investing through downturns rather than cutting back when rivals do.

The chart below shows the recovery in numbers. Revenue reached a record $10.4 billion in the second quarter of 2026, while the operating margin climbed from a low near 4% in early 2025 back above 15%. This is the cyclical upswing that lifted earnings and, with them, the share price.

The Earnings Recovery

Nucor is in the middle of a strong earnings recovery. Earnings per share fell to a low of $0.77 in the first quarter of 2025 as steel prices weakened. They have climbed almost every quarter since, reaching $4.84 in the second quarter of 2026, which beat the analyst estimate of $4.57. For full-year 2026, analysts now expect about $18.43 per share, more than double the $7.71 Nucor earned in 2025.

Analysts have been raising those numbers, not cutting them. The consensus estimate for fiscal-year 2027 has moved up from about $15.65 ninety days ago to about $18.23 today, a rise of roughly 16%. Six analysts raised their 2027 estimate in the past 30 days, against one who cut. Rising forecasts, with almost no downgrades, are one of the signals our screen looks for. The chart below shows that climb.

Honesty matters here. The jump in 2026 is a recovery from a weak 2025, not open-ended growth. Analysts expect 2027 earnings to hold near the 2026 level rather than climb further, so the growth rate from this year to next is roughly flat. The case for Nucor rests on a high and recovering level of earnings bought at a low price, not on a steep growth ramp.

Valuation: Cheap on Earnings, a Fair Premium on Book

For all that quality, Nucor is not expensively priced. It trades near 14 times next year's expected earnings, below the roughly 22 times the broad US market carries, and close to the 13 times median of its steel peers. On EV/EBITDA, Nucor sits near 11 times, actually below the steel-peer median of 15 times. Peers look more expensive on this measure because their depressed trough earnings inflate the multiple.

The one place Nucor carries a premium is Price-to-Book, at 2.7 times versus 1.7 times for the steel-peer group. That premium is earned. When a company turns each dollar of book value into more profit than its rivals, year after year, the market pays more per dollar of book. Ignoring valuation is never without risk, and we respect investors who demand a lower multiple. Paying a fair price for the highest-quality operator in an industry is simply a different choice from paying a rich multiple on hope.

The average analyst price target is about $280, roughly 9% above the recent price of $257. Ten of the fifteen analysts covering the stock rate it a buy or strong buy, five rate it hold, and none rate it a sell. These are analyst estimates, not a forecast we make or endorse. If the upward revisions to 2026 and 2027 earnings continue, targets could move higher. The stock already sits close to the current consensus, though, so we do not lean on that gap as the reason to own it.

How Nucor Passed Our Three-Pillar Process

Nucor did not enter the portfolio because we have a view on steel prices. It entered because it passed a systematic, repeatable process built on three pillars: Stock Universe, Optimizer and Risk Overlay.

Pillar 1: Stock Universe

The first pillar screens a broad investable universe on fundamental quality, the direction of earnings estimates, and price strength. Whatever names and sectors post the strongest fundamentals rise to the top of the list. Nucor cleared that screen on profitability well above its steel peers, on a steady run of upward earnings revisions, and on price strength after a strong year. The screen applies no hard valuation cap, so Nucor's low multiple was a bonus rather than a requirement. We explain the wider construction in Portfolio Construction: Why 15–30 Stocks Is the Sweet Spot.

Pillar 2: Optimizer

The Optimizer decides which qualified names to hold, not how big each position should be. Every position is equal-weighted within the invested part of the book. With equity exposure currently near 81% across 15 names, each position is a little over 5% of the account, Nucor included. Adding a steelmaker alongside our technology, energy, financial and healthcare names also spreads the portfolio across parts of the market that do not all move together. We cover this in How the Optimizer Limits Concentration.

Pillar 3: Risk Overlay

The third pillar sets how much of the book is invested at all. Every night, the system recalculates more than 20 risk indicators across markets and sets our equity exposure for the next day. It is time-tested to control drawdown, not to predict prices. This matters for a name like Nucor, whose beta is about 1.9. In a broad market decline a high-beta name falls hardest, and that is exactly when the overlay's exposure cut does the most to cushion the whole book.

One honest limit: the overlay reads market-wide risk and sets exposure for the entire portfolio. It does not protect a single stock that falls on its own while the rest of the market holds up. If steel prices roll over in an otherwise healthy market, the overlay will not offset that. Two other parts of the process handle single-name risk instead. Equal weighting keeps any one name to roughly one-fifteenth of the invested book, and monthly re-qualification means a stock whose fundamentals break can drop out at the next rebalance. Our latest June 2026 monthly review shows the overlay adjusting exposure in real conditions.

Catalysts on the Radar

• Next earnings. Nucor's next quarterly results are due in October 2026, with full-year consensus around $18.43 per share.
• Continued revisions. Further upward estimate changes are likely if steel prices and shipment volumes hold.
• Trade policy. US tariffs on imported steel support domestic pricing and Nucor's volumes.
• Reshoring and infrastructure. Domestic manufacturing investment and infrastructure spending lift long-run steel demand.
• New mill capacity. The ramp of new domestic mill projects can add volume as it comes online.

“The highest-margin operator in a tough industry, bought at a fair price, and held only as long as the data supports it.”

Related reading. For how a steelmaker fits a book that began in technology, see Sector Rotation: Are We an AI Portfolio?. For why owning quality over full cycles matters, see Long-Term Investing: How Compounding Wins.

This deep dive is for education and is not investment advice. Nucor (NUE) is a current Veloris Capital portfolio holding as of the publication date. We are a Popular Investor on eToro. If you choose to copy the strategy, eToro technically replicates our trades proportionally into your own account, which stays under your control at all times. Past performance is not an indication of future results. Your capital is at risk.

Monthly investment briefing — our live F1 status, month-to-date results against the S&P 500 and Nasdaq-100, what changed in the book and what's ahead. Optional instant alerts whenever we publish. No spam.